Kumar Rakesh
New York ,USA. 1st November. With the 2024 US presidential election heating up, Bharatiya Americans find themselves at a pivotal juncture. As one of the fastest-growing and most influential immigrant communities in the United States, their votes could shape the electoral landscape, especially in swing states where margins are tight. But whom are they rallying behind this time – Donald Trump or Kamala Harris? The choice reflects a mix of economic, cultural, and geopolitical priorities unique to the Bharatiya American experience.
Bharatiya American Voting Power: A Community on the Rise
Bharatiya Americans, estimated at over 4.5 million, are not only the second-largest immigrant group in the US but are also increasingly active in politics. Known for high levels of education and economic success, they represent a demographic with both significant voting power and influence. Traditionally leaning Democratic, a shift among Bharatiya Americans could have meaningful implications for candidates on either side.
Economic Appeal: Trump’s Support Among Conservative Bharatiya Americans
For many Bharatiya Americans, particularly entrepreneurs and professionals, Trump’s economic policies hold appeal. His approach to tax cuts, business-friendly regulations, and a focus on job creation resonates with those in high-income brackets, a sizable portion of the Bharatiya American population. Business owners and high-earning professionals see in Trump an advocate for policies that could enhance their financial security and entrepreneurial prospects.
Additionally, some conservative Bharatiya Americans feel aligned with Trump’s focus on merit-based immigration and preference for high-skilled immigrants, which he has publicly supported. Though controversial for others, these policies are often seen by conservative Bharatiya Americans as beneficial for professionals seeking job opportunities and career advancement in the United States.
Kamala Harris: A Symbol of Representation and Heritage
Kamala Harris’s position as the Democratic vice-presidential candidate offers a level of representation that resonates deeply with Bharatiya Americans. With roots in Chennai through her late mother, Harris represents the community on a personal level, symbolizing the success and integration of Bharatiya Americans in mainstream politics. Her nomination is a source of pride, particularly for younger Bharatiya Americans who see her heritage as a bridge between two worlds.
Harris’s Bharatiya background and her history of advocating for immigrant rights align with the values of many Bharatiya Americans who prioritize social justice, diversity, and inclusion. For those invested in progressive values, her leadership is seen as a win for multiculturalism and a symbol of how far the Bharatiya American community has come in the political landscape.
Foreign Policy: US-Bharat Relations on the Ballot
For Bharatiya Americans, the US relationship with Bharat is a significant factor. Trump’s tenure was marked by visible gestures of goodwill toward Bharat, highlighted by events like the “Howdy Modi” rally and his support for Bharat in its geopolitical rivalry with China. His vocal endorsement of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and a tough stance on China have garnered him considerable support among Bharatiya Americans who prioritize a strong US-Bharat alliance.
However, many Bharatiya Americans believe that the Biden-Harris administration also maintains a firm commitment to US-Bharat relations, albeit with a focus on democracy and human rights. While this approach has led to mixed reactions, some Bharatiya Americans appreciate the balanced stance, valuing policies that foster diplomatic engagement while upholding democratic values.
Social Justice and Religious Freedom: A Divisive Issue
Social justice and religious freedom are critical issues for Bharatiya Americans, especially as the younger generation leans into topics like racial equity and anti-discrimination. Trump’s policies on immigration and his handling of racial justice issues have been divisive, leading some Bharatiya Americans to prefer the Democratic Party’s more inclusive approach to civil rights and social equality.
On the other hand, Trump’s administration has actively engaged with Hindu American organizations, recognizing Hindu festivals and emphasizing religious freedom. This outreach has created a sense of cultural visibility that resonates with some Bharatiya American conservatives, who feel more recognized under the Republican administration than before.
Immigration Policy: Balancing Opportunity with Restriction
Immigration policy is a significant factor for Bharatiya Americans, many of whom are directly impacted by work visa policies like the H-1B. Trump’s administration enacted restrictions on H-1B visas, creating frustration among some Bharatiya Americans. However, his support for a merit-based immigration system is viewed positively by others, particularly those who believe this policy favors high-skilled immigrants and could be beneficial in the long term.
For Bharatiya Americans who prioritize a more open immigration policy, Harris’s Democratic platform represents a chance for reform. The Biden-Harris administration’s stance on comprehensive immigration reform and support for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program aligns with Bharatiya Americans who favor family unification and a more flexible approach to visas and green cards.
Generational Perspectives: A Community Split by Age and Ideology
The Bharatiya American community is far from monolithic. A generational divide shapes political preferences: younger Bharatiya Americans, who tend to prioritize progressive policies, are more likely to support Harris. They see in the Democratic Party a commitment to issues such as climate action, social justice, and racial equity, which align with their values.
In contrast, older Bharatiya Americans, who value economic stability and traditional values, may lean toward Trump. This demographic often prioritizes tax benefits, a strong US-Bharat relationship, and a more conservative approach to immigration, aligning more closely with the Republican platform.
The Swing State Factor: How Bharatiya Americans Could Influence the Outcome
Bharatiya Americans are concentrated in key states like Texas, Florida, Pennsylvania, and Michigan — all crucial battlegrounds in the upcoming election. Their voting preferences could tip the balance, particularly if a significant shift occurs among traditionally Democratic voters moving toward Trump or undecided voters swaying toward Harris.
Conclusion: A Community Cautious Yet Powerful
As the 2024 US election approaches, Bharatiya Americans find themselves facing a complex choice between Trump and Harris. Some see Trump’s policies as aligning with their economic and geopolitical interests, including a strong US-Bharat partnership and a tough stance on China. For others, Harris’s representation, commitment to social justice, and pro-immigration stance paint a picture of a more inclusive America.
Across key areas with substantial Hindu populations—such as Brooklyn, Times Square, Junction Boulevard, and Jackson Heights—a consensus is emerging on two main strategies: First, to quietly observe the stances of both parties and candidates, watching closely for alignment with Hindu American interests in terms of policy, cultural respect, and international relations. Second, many Hindu American leaders and office bearers are urging individuals to vote independently and thoughtfully, weighing each candidate’s platform in relation to their values and long-term goals.
While the Hindu American community may not rally uniformly behind either Trump or Harris, their collective strategic patience reflects a growing political maturity and influence. This cautious approach sends a clear signal: the Hindu American vote is not guaranteed but must be earned. Bharatiya Americans, divided by priorities but united in their intent to make a calculated impact, are choosing considered engagement over partisan loyalty. With both candidates appealing to different facets of their identity and values, Bharatiya Americans stand poised to play a decisive role in an election that resonates across cultures and continents.
Comments are closed.